The Witcher 3: A Guide to the Sins of the Flesh (2023)

quick links

  • Priscilla griff an
  • sewerage
  • The morgue
  • three lanes
  • The killer at Vegelbud
  • Nathanial and completing the alternate mission
  • Fight with the katakan

the witcher 3is set in a world full of criminals and their violence, but a particularly gruesome situation comes in the form of a horrific serial killer roaming the streets of Novigrad. As part of the Carnal Sins mission, Geralt must investigate a series of murders to find the real culprit.

RELATED:The Witcher 3: Get Youth Side Quest Guide

If you're looking to complete this side quest and don't mind a little gruesome violence, turns out our guide has you covered.

Updated December 7, 2022 by Quinton O'Connor:Carnal Sins isn't the easiest side quest in The Witcher 3. Not only is it a bit tricky in itself; You can fail miserably easily. You'll still get a reward, but the narrative satisfaction just won't be there for you. We've reworked this one to better keep players away from this unfortunate ending.


Priscilla griff an

The Witcher 3: A Guide to the Sins of the Flesh (1)

This quest is available after completing Cabaret, which is unlocked after completing the main story quest A Poet Under Pressure. It starts with Geralt talking to Jaskier in the chameleon. A messenger from the local hospital will come in and inform them both that Jaskier's good friend Priscilla has been attacked. The two are taken to the hospital.

Upon arrival, you will find Chief Physician Joachim von Gratz examining Priscilla, who has been the victim of a horrific attack. The doctor will tell you that Priscilla is not the first victim of this type of attack.He will then ask you to go to the morgue to examine the last victim, hoping you can track down this killer.


The Witcher 3: A Guide to the Sins of the Flesh (2)

Geralt and the doctor will go through the sewers below to the morgue.Novigrad. You know, Geralt must be spending a lot of time down here.Go deep and go to the location marked on your map.

(Video) 12 Things The Witcher 3 Doesn't Tell You

You will meet some along the wayDrowning and a water witch. They're not too difficult to defeat; Just use your fire-based attacks like Igni and Dragon's Dream when you're having trouble.

Von Gratz will discuss the attacks and state that he believes Priscilla will be fine, but he worries about her singing voice. Eventually, you will reach a staircase to go to the morgue.

The morgue

The Witcher 3: A Guide to the Sins of the Flesh (3)

Once they reach the morgue, Geralt must perform an autopsy.You must search the corpse of the dwarven woodcarver to the northeast.You can go through any of the dialogue options if you like and then give the doctor your verdict. They are interrupted by two people: the coroner,Hubert Rejk, and the Reverend,Nathanael Pastodi.

You can talk to the doctor after you leave, about these two men, but he won't give you much information about either of them, apart from some vague details.But he will mention that Hubert "hasn't changed much" in 30 years, he still looks relatively young compared to him.Curious.

You now have three potential customers:the corpse collector, the site of the woodcarver's death, and the site of Priscilla's attack.

three lanes

The Witcher 3: A Guide to the Sins of the Flesh (4)

The collector's fault

The next clue is the Corpse Collector, so it's advisable to go there first. You can find him in a scene where some corpses are being collected. Talk toEustace the Gatherer, and he gets nervous when you ask him questions.You have to bribe him with 200 crowns or trick him with Axii if you have the second level of Delusion.

(Video) The Witcher 3 FULL Beginners Guide & Best Tips and Tricks! (2022)

If you choose the latter of the two options, you will receive 40 experience points. Towards the end of the conversation he will make a comment about Priscilla and you can hit him. We're not saying you should do it, but you absolutely should.

The Woodcarver's Murder

Then go to the place where the woodcarver was killed to investigate what happened.You can find the marker on your map near Hierarch Square. He knocks on the large wooden doors and finds a dwarf who is a little suspicious of who is knocking. Once he lets you in, you can talk to him about the other dwarf you killed. You won't have much to say to our warlock, but you can do your own research.

Use your Witcher Senses to find a pool of blood and some drag marks and some burned statues. You'll also find a "sermon from a concerned citizen" implying the Church of Eternal Fire.. Find the locked workshop and let the dwarf open it. Here are more things to investigate with your Witcher Sense. After that, you can talk to the dwarf one more time before leaving.

The final location to examine is where Priscilla was attacked.

crime scene

Here you will find a guard who will tell you that there has been another victim.Use your witcher senses to look around the area.Eventually a woman will attack you with some bats. After you win the fight, he will tell you that they were in the area to take down Priscilla's attackers.since the perpetrator usually returns to the scene of the crime.

When you use your witcher senses again, a trace of the smell of formaldehyde becomes visible.Follow him and research along the way to eventually find another "Sermon from a Concerned Citizen". Geralt will mention that the killer appears to have jumped over a wall that even a warlock could not easily scale.

Head back to the coroner who is nearby and speak to him again to learn a few more things. It's important to note that one of those things is that there isa note naming the next victim.

RELATED:The Witcher 3: Father Knows Worst Side Quest-Tutorial

(Video) The Witcher 3 ULTIMATE Guide to Alchemy 2021 [EVERYTHING YOU DIDN'T KNOW]

The killer at Vegelbud

The Witcher 3: A Guide to the Sins of the Flesh (5)

Geralt will choose to go straight to the Vegelbud residence. You talk to Ingrid Vegelbud, who tells you about the pyre that burned on the site due to Patricia's doubts about her faith. Unfortunately you will see a really horrible scene where Patricia was tied up and killed.HappilyAt least you got there when the killer left.

Follow him until you meet some guards who think you are the killer.After fighting them off for a while, a scene begins where Ingrid stands up for you and allows you to perform an autopsy on Patricia's body. You will find a note explaining thisVerkrüppelte Kate Sweet Nettieis the next victim.

Nathanial and completing the alternate mission

The Witcher 3: A Guide to the Sins of the Flesh (6)

Dirigete a Crippled Kate'swhether on a quick ride or a long ride. Inside, talk to a man who will tell you that Sweet Nettie is upstairs with an important client.

Find Sweet Nettie and Reverend Nathaniel above. You need to respond quickly to a timed dialog quicktime event. If you choose "Try him, asshole" or any other angry response that follows, you will have to fight him.If you follow this path you will end up killing him and the quest will end shortly after. However, he will not have been able to determine who the real killer is.

For a more complete ending to the quest, be on your best behavior when you speak to the Reverend and he will give you the information you need. During the conversation, select the dialogue option."Simply that way? No formaldehyde?" and then"So who left the letter on Patricia's body?"He will tell you where to find the real killer.

(Video) New Game Plus Guide : The Witcher 3 Wild Hunt

After that you can let him torment Sweet Nettie or, if you have a conscience,Use Axii on him or fight him to get him to leave her alone.If you decide to kill him at this point or with the previous option, you will get100 experience points, training pants, a poker and a diagram for the Ard Skellige Aketon.If you use Axii on it, you will get 40 experience points.

Related:The Witcher 3: The Mystery of The Byways Murders Side Quest Tutorial

Fight with the katakan

The Witcher 3: A Guide to the Sins of the Flesh (7)

From there, travel to the Novigrad Docks warehouse marked on your map. You'll find the coroner with some formaldehyde. He will admit the crimes and tell you why he did what he did. He took it upon himself to do the will of the Church. Needless to say, a fight breaks out.

Use Quen and Igni whenever possible, and be sure to use your vampire oil. Black blood will also come in handy here. Watch your back and keep hitting when you have a clear shot and it should go down pretty quickly.

Loot the corpse to get the Silver Sword of Deargdeith, a Katakan Mutagen, and a Rubedo Bundle. Go back to talk to Dandelion and Priscilla who is recovering. The full version of "Carnal sins" ends like this.

For finding the real killer you get500 experience points, a blueprint for the assassin's boots, and a smaller Svarog runestone.

If you choose to kill Nathaniel before learning the true culprit's identity, you will not receive these final items or experience points. However, the real killer leaves a note in the morgue explaining who he is and that he's leaving town, so you still know who he is, albeit with less satisfaction.

(Video) The Witcher 3 BEST Tips and Tricks for NEW & RETURNING Players - The Witcher 3 Next Gen Update

NEXT:The Witcher 3: Complete Guide and Walkthrough


Is there any way to save Patricia Vegelbud? ›

Rush off to the Vegelbud Estate to try and save Miss Patricia Vegelbud! Either use Roach or Fast Travel to get there as quickly as possible. Head up the estate, convincing both the guard and Patricia's daughter to let you see her.

What was the answer to the autopsy in Witcher? ›

The autopsy showed Kalkstein was the murderer. It would be hard to find a better proof of his working for Azar. The autopsy proved Kalkstein was the murderer.

What happens if you tell the peasants about the Allgod? ›

Consequences Of Decisions Made During A Greedy God

Killing the Allgod will upset the peasants, despite the revelation that their god was just a random monster, and they can later be found in the town of Claywich. You'll earn 50 XP for the quest.

Can you catch the killer in Vegelbud? ›

Travel to the Vegelbud Estate, argue your way in past the gate guard, and speak with Ingrid, Priscilla's daughter. She'll eventually lead you to her mother's bedroom, where you almost catch the killer red-handed. Chase off after him, avoiding the estate guards, but alas - they prevent you catching the murderer.

Can you save both Detlaff and Syanna? ›

Some people prefer saving Detlaff and Killing Syanna, others want to save Syanna. To save both sisters you have to get the ribbon from the flint girl in the Land of Fables. (So you cannot go to the Elder during the night the long fangs.) The ribbon will save Syanna.

What is the hardest fight in Witcher 3? ›

1 Dettlaff

Also known as The Beast of Beauclair, Dettlaff van der Eretein is a higher vampire that shows up in the Blood and Wine expansion and is considered by many to be the game's toughest enemy.

What happens if you sleep with Sasha Witcher 3? ›

Romancing Sasha has no impact on the rest of the game and the other romance options that Geralt can pursue. Later on in the game, you'll come across an optional quest called 'High Stakes'. It requires Geralt to enter a Gwent tournament at the Passiflora in Novigrad.

What is the hardest quest in Witcher 3? ›

The Witcher 3: 5 Hardest Side Quests (& 5 That Are Surprisingly Easy)
  • 6/10 Hardest: Towerful Of Mice.
  • 5/10 Surprisingly Easy: A Matter Of Life And Death.
  • 4/10 Hardest: Carnal Sins.
  • 3/10 Surprisingly Easy: Big Game Hunter.
  • 2/10 Hardest: There Can Only Be One.
  • 1/10 Surprisingly Easy: The Cave Of Dreams.

Is Kalkstein innocent? ›

Kalkstein deemed innocent by any means:

The evidence suggests Kalkstein's innocence.

Can you prevent Vesemir death? ›

You can't do this later because it's impossible to save Vesemir at the end of the conflict with Eredin and his troops. It's worth doing, too, as you get a bonus interaction with the experienced Witcher.

What was the thing that killed Eskels Leshy? ›

When Eskel arrived at Kaer Morhen he greeted Geralt and the other witchers. Then, he went on to tell his tale with the leshy, but displayed suspicion about its nature. Vesemir then reminded him how a leshy is only killed by fire through the heart.

Can you exile Hilde? ›

Before you reveal who it is, you can tell him the person could simply be exiled or let them be killed. After that, once you reveal it's Hilde, Sven will either agree to let her be killed if you chose the killing method, or inform them to run her out of town and not come back if you chose the exile method.

What happens if you break Dijkstra leg? ›

Thanks in advance! If you shove Dijkstra away, you will miss the chance to play the plot to kill Radovid. You also lose all credit with him, and you cannot count on any help from him later on.

Should you let Keira go to Radovid? ›

If you convince Keira to go to Kaer Morhen, she will join you for The Battle of Kaer Morhen. If she doesn't go to Kaer Morhen, the Brothers In Arms: Velen quest later will automatically fail. If you let Keira go to Radovid (or didn't do the quest at all), this will later unlock the secondary quest A Final Kindness.

Can you save Priscilla? ›

Priscilla had been horribly wounded and her life hung by a thread. Whoever had done this to her did not deserve to live on this earth a moment longer. In a miracle of skill and learning, the brilliant surgeon Joachim von Gratz was able to save Priscilla and set her on the long, hard road to recovery.

Can I save Philippa Eilhart? ›

You can convince him to let you pass or kill him, but he doesn't drop any loot, so that's not worth doing. Once you reach Philippa she will summon a Fire elemental and you will have to kill it while also avoiding her attacks.

Is there a way to save Detlaff? ›

If you seek her during the Night of the Long Fangs, but choose not to take the ribbon in the Fairy Tale world, Detlaff kills her at Tesham Mutna. Then you can choose to kill Detlaff or let him escape, but the Duchess won't be too impressed either way.

Is it better for Ciri to become empress? ›

Despite her powers, Ciri hasn't undergone the Trial of Grasses, so she doesn't have the enhanced physical prowess or longevity of a Witcher. Being an empress is a safer option for Ciri, and the comforts, protection, and amenities such a lifestyle provides means she'll probably live a far longer time.

Should I save Detlaff or Syanna? ›

The better, and most moral ending in my opinion is to let Dettlaff go and let Syanna die. Yes, Anna Henrietta is heartbroken about her sister's death, and angry at Geralt... But it just feels like the better choice.

Can you complete both wine wars quests? ›

Wine Wars: Vermentino/Coronato

The two quests run over each other and can be tackled in either order. You can either do all five of one and return to Plegmund's Bridge for your reward, or you can just do the Guarded Treasure at both to unlock another quest.

Who is the hardest boss in The Witcher 3? ›

The Elder Vampire will use all his force to take down Geralt, making him arguably the hardest boss in the entire Witcher franchise.

Should I play Witcher 3 on highest difficulty? ›

If you've played it before, however, and the new version of the game is encouraging you to consider a replay, then I have some advice: You should start your new game on the highest difficulty, Death March.

Who is Geralt's true love? ›

Geralt of Rivia

Can you romance Ciri? ›

Ciri also has some romance options in the new game, and it's up to you to choose who she'll end up with. So, buckle up and check out your options – and how to achieve them.

Who is Ciri love interest? ›

Who is the love interest of Ciri? Ciri has a romantic relationship with an girl named Mistle while a member of the outlaw gang “The Rats”. We also see her express romantic interest in a knight named Ser Galahad in the final Witcher book Lady of the Lake.

How many hours does it take to 100 Witcher 3? ›

When focusing on the main objectives, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is about 51½ Hours in length. If you're a gamer that strives to see all aspects of the game, you are likely to spend around 173 Hours to obtain 100% completion.

Is it possible to not fail any quests Witcher 3? ›

The Witcher 3 has a few quests that can actually auto-fail if you aren't careful.
King's Gambit.
Stranger In A Strange LandThis quest obligates Geralt to take on the next quest.80 Experience
1 more row
Jun 27, 2022

What quests can you miss in Witcher 3? ›

  • 18 An Eye for an Eye.
  • 17 Precious Cargo.
  • 16 The Lord of Undvik.
  • 15 Ciri's Room.
  • 14 A Dog's Life.
  • 13 The Gangs of Novigrad.
  • 12 Carnal Sins.
  • 11 On Death's Bed.
Jan 3, 2023

Is Ramsmeat innocent? ›

The evidence suggests that Ramsmeat is innocent.

How do you prove Vincent is innocent? ›

For Vincent, Finding out Coleman is Vincent's informant when you meet Coleman on the Dike during The Rat quest will provide the "Definitive Proof" for his innocence.

How to prove that Thaler is innocent? ›

Paradoks: You have to complete Shani's party to get proof that Thaler is innocent. Not true! Although that is one way to do it. Once you've seen the mysterious man and talked to him, and he says "you didn't see me", you have to go back and talk to Thaler again, EVEN THOUGH HIS DIALOGUE OPTIONS ARE GREYED OUT.

Who is the oldest witcher ever? ›

Vesemir is the oldest and most experienced witcher at Kaer Morhen. He is a father figure to Geralt and the other witchers.

Was Geralt a child of surprise? ›

Geralt unknowingly names Ciri as his reward a second time when he saves the life of Yurga, for while the man was away, his wife took in the orphan girl. Geralt himself is a victim of the Law of Surprise. It was because of the Law of Surprise that Geralt was taken in as a Witcher.

Can you talk to Triss before the battle of Kaer Morhen? ›

No. Triss will only go to Kaer Morhen if you ask her to stay AND tell her you love her. If you don't, she will leave for good.

Does Eskel like Ciri? ›

Eskel is widely considered a fan-favorite. In the saga of Geralt and Ciri (Freya Allan in the show), he, alongside Geralt, is in charge of Ciri's witcher training. His impact on Ciri's life and future is significant, and it is clear that, despite his initial doubts, he cares for her and wants her to succeed.

Did Eskel turn into a Leshen? ›

Eskel meets a grim end in the second episode of the new season. Tragically, it's Geralt who's forced to cut down his old ally after a mysterious infection causes him to transform into a monstrous Leshen.

Did Geralt sleep with Fringilla Vigo? ›

Fringilla's affair with Geralt was initially strategic but emotions got involved and she ended up falling for him. It was a rather dysfunctional affection since Geralt, at one point during the height of their lovemaking, mistakenly referred to Fringilla as Yennefer.

Should I talk to Harald or Sven? ›

Remember: If you go with Harald's offer you won't get to fight the Woodland Spirit and will miss this trophy! You must talk to Sven instead!

What to do with the Leshen? ›

The Leshen will start summoning Jagras - which Igni can kill in one hit. Ideally, Wait for the Jagras to crowd around the Leshen, and hit them all with Igni in one shot. If Igni isn't up, keep the Jagras at bay for a time with a Flash Pod.

How to tell Sven about Hilde? ›

If You Side With Sven

Using your Witcher Senses will reveal the marked person, Hilde. This young woman seems to have a romantic involvement with Sven, complicating matters. Return to Sven with this news and tell him that the person can be killed or exiled. Then, tell him it's Hilde.

Can Ciri become empress if I side with Dijkstra? ›

Can Ciri become empress if Dijkstra lives? Dijsktra will not be able to rule over Novigrad. This only will happen IF you visit Emhyr AND side with Vernon Roche. If you side with Dijkstra or let Radovid live, even if you visit Emhyr, this ending will not happen.

What happens if Dijkstra becomes king? ›

Geralt then helps assassinate Radovid and lets Dijkstra kill Roche, Ves, and Thaler. If he does that, Dijkstra becomes the new ruler. He will rule Redania using fear and intimidation, and people will lose their freedom — but the Continent's industry will prosper.

Why did Geralt break Dijkstra's ankle? ›


Geralt has already rendered Dijkstra disabled by breaking his leg. Geralt apparently had no qualms on doing this again after Dijkstra wanted to conclude unfinished business with Philippa. Dijkstra was well within his ethical rights, of course, but Geralt was out of time.

Does Keira romance affect Yen? ›

Romancing Keira has no impact on the rest of the game and the other romance options that Geralt can pursue. Geralt will meet with Keira as part of the main story in Velen.

How do I avoid killing Keira? ›

In essence, just don't be a jerk with her, try to understand the person she is, and when the opportunity arises (when she tells Geralt that she's going to Radovid), tell her that's suicide, and there's a better way: go to Kaer Morhen.

Does it matter if you sleep with Keira Metz? ›

No, sleeping with Keira doesn't ruin your other romances in the game. For the record, if you romance Triss and then sleep with Yen during the feast in Skellige (but don't tell her you still love her in The Last Wish sidequest), you don't get the "Lone Wolf" ending either.

Is it possible to save Priscilla? ›

Priscilla had been horribly wounded and her life hung by a thread. Whoever had done this to her did not deserve to live on this earth a moment longer. In a miracle of skill and learning, the brilliant surgeon Joachim von Gratz was able to save Priscilla and set her on the long, hard road to recovery.

Can you save dettlaff? ›

If you seek her during the Night of the Long Fangs, but choose not to take the ribbon in the Fairy Tale world, Detlaff kills her at Tesham Mutna. Then you can choose to kill Detlaff or let him escape, but the Duchess won't be too impressed either way.

What happens if you let Priscilla stay Witcher 3? ›

Priscilla will show up to deliver a message. You may decide to let her stay or go. It doesn't matter either way. You can also play Gwent to pass the time, if you'd like.

Can you get back into the Vegelbud residence? ›

Access to the main part of the estate is restricted and Geralt cannot enter under most circumstances. The only times he is able to enter the grounds is during A Matter of Life and Death and Carnal Sins, and the only time the interior of the house can be explored is during Carnal Sins.

Why is Dandelion called Jaskier? ›

When translated directly from Polish to English, Jaskier means Buttercup, a name that doesn't quite properly fit the bard's personality. So instead of Buttercup, the translator opted to change Jaskier's name to Dandelion, seeing that it better fit the character.

Who is the real killer in Witcher 3? ›

Geralt had already figured out Rejk was the true murderer, but was shocked to learn he was also a powerful vampire.

Can you save Lady Vivienne? ›

Curing Vivienne

If Guillaume was told more information about the curse, Vivienne will be open to using the alternate option to curing her, otherwise she'll want to use the egg to cure her. Once at the hidden clearing, follow Vivienne towards the glade. You'll need to kill a panther here.

Can you keep Vesemir alive? ›

Yet, before the war against The Wild Hunt starts, you should do the Berengar's Blade quest, which requires talking to Vesemir. You can't do this later because it's impossible to save Vesemir at the end of the conflict with Eredin and his troops.

Does Yen get mad if you drink with the witchers? ›

Having A Drink With Your Allies

Eventually, things get heated between Yen and Lambert. You can tell the Witcher to mind his manners, but it doesn't alter the scene too much. After the argument, Yen goes to bed and tells you not to stay up too late.

Which mask should Geralt wear? ›

Geralt and Triss are required to prepare, and Triss must have a fox mask for this. Triss tasks Geralt to visit the tailor shop owned by Elihal to buy the fox mask, he can also buy other masks and some elegant outfits he can use. Elegant outfit can be also obtained for free from madame Irina Renarde.

Where is Triss after A Matter of Life and Death? ›

Go to Triss' hideout to see what she needed help with. Triss received a message from Lady Ingrid Vegelbud, who you may remember from the side quest “Carnal Sins.” Triss needs to meet a man in the fish market. Go in her stead, while she waits out nearby. Leave the hideout and go to the fish market.


1. Witcher 3: Don't Miss These Quests in the Next Gen Edition.
2. How to get the 3 Hidden Ability Points in the Witcher 3 (Complete Walkthrough)
3. Witcher 3 - Best Runewright Enchanting + Guide
4. 5 Witcher Sign Details You Probably Missed | THE WITCHER 3
5. The Witcher 3: Flesh for sale
6. Witcher 3 - A Guide to Gwent (Or how to get more spies)
(Proper Bird)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Annamae Dooley

Last Updated: 11/03/2022

Views: 6420

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (65 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Annamae Dooley

Birthday: 2001-07-26

Address: 9687 Tambra Meadow, Bradleyhaven, TN 53219

Phone: +9316045904039

Job: Future Coordinator

Hobby: Archery, Couponing, Poi, Kite flying, Knitting, Rappelling, Baseball

Introduction: My name is Annamae Dooley, I am a witty, quaint, lovely, clever, rich, sparkling, powerful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.